El Greco fallacy
The El Greco fallacy is typically a perceptive fallacy, where it is assumed that particular perceptual abnormalities will influence interactions with the world of a similar nature. It is named after an erroneous explanation for the vertically distorted painting style of El Greco, which held that the artist must have seen the world as distorted by a peculiar astigmatism, and thus painted this distorted world. This theoretical astigmatism cannot explain El Greco's style though, as he would have seen his canvases distorted in the same way, and painting onto them would have cancelled out any distortion.
It is believed the term originated with Irvin Rock, in his 1966 book, The Nature of Perceptual Adaptation.[1][2]
When explored in experiment — by having subjects wear distorting lenses — it seems likely that El Greco would have completely adapted to seeing a distorted world, and this could not have been an explanation.[3]
In perception research
Chaz Firestone and Brian Scholl have alleged that this fallacy has been the cause for mistaken thinking in perception research,[1][4] including in studies that presumed to show that wearing a heavy backpack makes hills literally appear steeper, or holding rods outstretched horizontally would make doorways look narrower.
In the example of holding rods outstretched, the original experiment had subjects evaluate the width of apertures (intended to simulate doorways), then show this width on a ruler held by experimenters. The width was evaluated as narrower by those holding rods than those who were not.[5] When Firestone and Scholl repeated this experiment, substituting rulers for a separate aperture that was adjusted by experimenters to the subjects instruction, the aperture was still evaluated as narrower. This narrowing effect was later implied to be a demand characteristic after another group was told that their holding a rod was an evaluation of balance abilities.[4]
References
- ^ a b Firestone, Chaz (2013). "On the origin and status of the 'El Greco fallacy'". Perception. 42 (6): 672–674. doi:10.1068/p7488. ISSN 1468-4233. PMID 24422249. S2CID 46387563.
- ^ Rock, Irvin (1966). The Nature of Perceptual Adaptation. Oxford: Basic Books.
- ^ Anstis, Stuart M. (2002). "Was El Greco Astigmatic?". Leonardo. 35 (2): 208. doi:10.1162/00240940252940612. ISSN 1530-9282. S2CID 57572184.
- ^ a b Firestone, Chaz; Scholl, Brian J. (2014). "'Top-down' effects where none should be found: the El Greco fallacy in perception research" (PDF). Psychological Science. 25 (1): 38–46. doi:10.1177/0956797613485092. ISSN 1467-9280. PMID 24297777. S2CID 6964130.
- ^ Stefanucci, Jeanine K.; Geuss, Michael N. (2009-01-01). "Big people, little world: the body influences size perception". Perception. 38 (12): 1782–1795. doi:10.1068/p6437. ISSN 0301-0066. PMC 3298356. PMID 20192128.
- v
- t
- e
- Adoration of the Magi (c. 1565–1567)
- Dormition of the Virgin (1565–1566)
- Healing of the Man Born Blind
- Dresden, 1567
- Parma, c. 1573
- Modena Triptych (1567–1569)
- Baptism of Christ (1567–1569)
- Last Supper (1568)
- Flight into Egypt (1570)
- Annunciation
- Prado, 1570
- Madrid, 1575–1576
- Illescas, 1600–1605
- Purification of the Temple
- Washington, 1570
- Minneapolis, 1570
- New York, 1595–1600
- London, 1600
- Madrid, 1609
- The Fable (1570–1575)
- Entombment of Christ (1570–1576)
- El Soplón (1571–1572)
- Pietà (1571–1576)
- Penitent Magdalene (1576–1578)
- Saint Sebastian (1576–1579)
- Santo Domingo el Antiguo Altarpiece (1577)
- Saint Lawrence's Vision of the Madonna and Child (1577)
- Adoration of the Holy Name of Jesus (1577–1579)
- Assumption of the Virgin (1577–1579)
- Disrobing of Christ (El Expolio) (1577–1579)
- Holy Trinity (c. 1577–1579)
- Saint Anthony of Padua (1580)
- Christ Carrying the Cross
- New York, c. 1580
- Barcelona, 1590–1595
- Madrid, 1597–1600
- The Martyrdom of Saint Maurice (1580–1582)
- The Tears of Saint Peter
- Barnard Castle, 1580–1589
- Mexico City, 1587–1596
- Oslo, c. 1590
- The Immaculate Conception with St John the Evangelist (c. 1585)
- The Burial of the Count of Orgaz (1586)
- Holy Family (1586–1588)
- Holy Face of Jesus (1586–1595)
- Saint Peter and Saint Paul
- Barcelona, 1587–1592
- Saint Petersburg, c. 1587–1592
- Agony in the Garden
- London, 1590
- Andújar, 1597–1607
- Christ on the Cross Adored by Two Donors (c. 1590)
- The Penitent Saint Peter (c. 1590–1595)
- Saint Louis (1592–1595)
- Virgin Mary (Mater Dolorosa) (c. 1594–1604)
- Holy Family (c. 1595)
- Christ Taking Leave of his Mother (1595)
- Saint Andrew and Saint Francis (1595–1598)
- Adoration of the Shepherds
- Bucharest, 1596
- Madrid, 1612–1614
- Doña María de Aragón Altarpiece (1596–1599)
- View of Toledo (1596–1600)
- Virgin Mary (1597)
- Saint Martin and the Beggar (1597–1599)
- The Virgin of Charity (1597–1603)
- Allegory of the Camaldolese Order (c. 1597)
- Saint John the Baptist (1597–1607)
- Saint John the Evangelist and Saint Francis (c. 1600)
- Saint Bernardino of Siena (1603)
- Nativity (1603–1605)
- Coronation of the Virgin (1603–1605)
- Marriage of the Virgin (1603–1607)
- Saint John the Evangelist (c. 1605)
- The Apparition of the Virgin to Saint Hyacinth (c. 1605–1610)
- The Immaculate Conception (1607–1613)
- Saint Peter (1608)
- View and Plan of Toledo (1608)
- Concert of Angels (1608)
- The Saviour (1608–1614)
- Saint Thomas the Apostle (1608–1614)
- Opening of the Fifth Seal (1608–1614)
- Saint Jerome (1609)
- Saint Ildefonsus (1609)
- Saint Francis and Brother Leo (1609)
- Saint James the Great (1610)
- Saint Luke (1610–1614)
- Laocoön (1610–1614)
- Saint Paul (1610–1614)
- Saint Sebastian (1610–1614)
- Julián Romero and Saint Julian (1612–1614)
- Portrait of Giulio Clovio (c. 1571)
- Portrait of Vincenzo Anastagi (1571–1576)
- The Nobleman with his Hand on his Chest (c. 1580)
- Portrait of a Doctor (1582–1585)
- Portrait of a Gentleman (c. 1586)
- Portrait of Rodrigo Vázquez de Arce (c. 1587–1597; lost, known from a copy)
- Portrait of an Elderly Man (1587–1600)
- Portrait of Antonio de Covarrubias (1595–1600)
- Self-Portrait (1595–1600)
- Portrait of Jorge Manuel Theotocópuli (c. 1597–1603)
- Portrait of a Young Nobleman (1600–1605)
- Cardinal Fernando Niño de Guevara (c. 1600)
- Portrait of an Unknown Gentleman (1603–1607)
- Portrait of Fray Hortensio Félix Paravacino (1609)
- Portrait of Juan Pardo de Tavera (1609)
- Portrait of Jerónimo de Cevallos (1609–1613)
- Portrait of Francisco de Pisa (1610–1614)
- Jorge Manuel Theotocópuli (son)
- Lady in Ermine (1947 film)
- El Greco (1966 film)
- El Greco (1998 album)
- El Greco (2007 film)
- El Greco fallacy