Season | Date | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Venue | Location | Attendance | Game MVP |
2001 | September 3 | Long Island Lizards | 15–11 | Baltimore Bayhawks | Kennedy Stadium | Bridgeport, CT | 6,745 | Paul Gait (Long Island) |
2002 | September 1 | Baltimore Bayhawks | 21–13 | Long Island Lizards | Columbus Crew Stadium | Columbus, OH | 5,596 | Mark Millon (Baltimore) |
2003 | August 24 | Long Island Lizards | 15–14 (OT) | Baltimore Bayhawks | Villanova Stadium | Villanova, PA | 6,593 | Kevin Lowe (Long Island) |
2004 | August 22 | Philadelphia Barrage | 13–11 | Boston Cannons | Nickerson Field | Boston, MA | 8,279 | Greg Cattrano (Philadelphia) |
2005 | August 21 | Baltimore Bayhawks | 15–9 | Long Island Lizards | Nickerson Field | Boston, MA | 6,829 | Gary Gait (Baltimore) |
2006 | August 27 | Philadelphia Barrage | 23–12 | Denver Outlaws | The Home Depot Center | Carson, CA | 5,374 | Roy Colsey (Philadelphia) |
2007 | August 26 | Philadelphia Barrage | 16–13 | Los Angeles Riptide | PAETEC Park | Rochester, NY | 5,288 | Matt Striebel (Philadelphia) |
2008 | August 24 | Rochester Rattlers | 16–6 | Denver Outlaws | Harvard Stadium | Boston, MA | 8,481 | Joe Walters (Rochester) |
2009 | August 23 | Toronto Nationals | 10–9 | Denver Outlaws | Navy–Marine Corps Memorial Stadium | Annapolis, MD | 7,003 | Merrick Thomson (Toronto) |
2010 | August 22 | Chesapeake Bayhawks | 13–9 | Long Island Lizards | Navy–Marine Corps Memorial Stadium | Annapolis, MD | 6,445 | Kyle Hartzell (Chesapeake) |
2011 | August 28 | Boston Cannons | 10–9 | Hamilton Nationals | Navy–Marine Corps Memorial Stadium | Annapolis, MD | 5,027 | Jordan Burke (Boston) |
2012 | August 26 | Chesapeake Bayhawks | 16–6 | Denver Outlaws | Harvard Stadium | Boston, MA | 7,384 | Ben Rubeor (Chesapeake) |
2013 | August 25 | Chesapeake Bayhawks | 10–9 | Charlotte Hounds | PPL Park | Chester, PA | 3,892 | John Grant Jr. (Chesapeake) |
2014 | August 23 | Denver Outlaws | 12–11 | Rochester Rattlers | Fifth Third Bank Stadium | Kennesaw, GA | 8,149 | John Grant Jr. (Denver) |
2015 | August 8 | New York Lizards | 15–12 | Rochester Rattlers | Fifth Third Bank Stadium | Kennesaw, GA | 8,674 | Paul Rabil (New York) |
2016 | August 20 | Denver Outlaws | 19–18 | Ohio Machine | Fifth Third Bank Stadium | Kennesaw, GA | 5,522 | Eric Law (Denver) |
2017 | August 19 | Ohio Machine | 17–12 | Denver Outlaws | The Ford Center at The Star | Frisco, TX | 7,543 | Marcus Holman (Ohio) |
2018 | August 18 | Denver Outlaws | 16-12 | Dallas Rattlers | MUSC Health Stadium | Charleston, SC | 4,086 | Matt Kavanagh (Denver) |
2019 | October 6 | Chesapeake Bayhawks | 10-9 | Denver Outlaws | Dick's Sporting Goods Park | Denver, CO | 6,374 | Steele Stanwick (Chesapeake) |
2020 | July 26 | Boston Cannons | 13-10 | Denver Outlaws | Navy-Marine Corps Memorial Stadium | Annapolis, MD | No fans due to COVID-19 pandemic | Not awarded |